Payments for environmental services in Costa Rica: Increasing efficiency through spatial differentiation


T. Wunscher; S. Engel; S. Wunder

Type of Document:
Scholarly Article


Humboldt Universitaet zu Berlin

Date of Publication:

Place of Publication:
Berlin, Germany


Abstract: Payments for Environmental Services (PES) have become a widely acknowledged and increasingly popular market based instrument to conserve forests and their environmental services. Costa Rica was the first developing country to have implemented a nationwide PES program. Besides legal and formal requirements which have to be met by any program applicant, the forest sites are selected from a pool of applications on the basis of predefined program areas. Sites inside these program areas qualify for participation, those outside do not, although exceptions are made. Assuming that more complex spatial differences do exist the efficiency of the PES program might be increased by considering a site’s actual service delivery potential, deforestation risk and by making not fixed, but flexible payments according to the site’s opportunity cost of forest conservation. Based on this data a selection mechanism is developed that maximizes additionality per dollar spent. Given a fixed budget results show that the selection mechanism increases the amount of contracted environmental services. Especially the use of flexible payment levels according to individual opportunity costs has a significantly positive impact on service delivery. Yet, as deforestation activities in Costa Rica are rare the use of deforestation probability estimates leads to little efficiency gain. It is also observed that the average area of the selected sites decreases which might indicate that the proposed selection mechanism encourages participation of the poor. For the implementation of flexible payments a PES program would need to estimate individual opportunity costs in a cost effective way. Three estimation approaches are tested and compared to the land owners

Additional Bibliographic Information

Quarterly Journal of International Agriculture 45(4): 317-35

Send us your questions or comments

Your Name (required)

Your Email (required)


Please enter this text: